Just a taste of Zoey’s background

As many of you know I bought Zoey from a pet store on the Upper East Side of Manhattan called Raising Rover and Baby. I was promised that Zoey was bred locally (untrue) and was not from a puppy mill (false). I do have the evidence to back this up. However, what I continue to find more disturbing is the continuous ads this store is pushing for its puppies online. One website had over 110puppies posted for them. This is ridiculous and this store needs to be stopped. What is even more disturbing is this statement taken directly from their ad:

“I am a real person in new york city with real puppies, this is not an internet purchase from a puppy farmer….”

Really? Really? So why did my puppy come from Missouri when you said she came from NY? And more importantly where in God’s name are you keeping all these dogs you are selling online if this is NOT an internet purchase and you are not buying from puppy mills? I decided to do a random check today and they currently have puppy ads up on the following sites: 1. hoobly.com 2. olx.com 3. backpage.com 4. villagevoice.com 5. puppyfind.com 6. mobile.domesticsale.com 7. puplistings.com (in which you changed your name…good job) 8. wagstreet.com 9. petsads.com 10. freedoglistings.com 11. k9stud.com 12. dogbreederdirectory.com 13. breedinfocenter.com 14. dogalot.netfirms.com Come on, lets be honest with ourselves. You are an internet purchaser and you do get your dogs from puppy mills. Quit trying to make money off these puppies and stick to your retail business. Stop lying to customers and quit making false reviews for yourself on places like citysearch and yelp.

Posted in News | Tagged , , , , , , , | Leave a comment

I’m shocked… a puppy mill… in my hometown?!!

So I am cruising around looking at different websites and surveying USDA inspection reports for dog breeders. A website here has a list of breeders in a few southern states along with their inspection reports. I guess Tulsa World ranked the worst dealers and breeders in Oklahoma and provides you with the “winners.” I look through the list and I see that there are other states on the list and they are not all just from Oklahoma. I see some from Arkansas, Kansas, Minnesota, etc. Then it catches my eye. I see my hometown.

My little hometown where I lived from 6th grade on up. Now mind you the 6th grade was a huge time in my life as I had a big transition with new schools, new friends and new surroundings, BUT I also got my one and only childhood gift I had wanted since I could speak:  I finally got my “collie dog.” I didn’t seem to have this obsession with Lassie or Timmy but I always knew I wanted a collie even in the Arkansas heat. I didn’t care about all her fur and grooming her…I would do it daily. I just wanted my collie and now I finally had her. She was loyal and protected me to the very end. I remember when I first started middle school in the middle of a semester she would be the one who I came home to each afternoon and explained my problems. She listened. I was not an animal rights activist but loved animals even though my father and mother were both hunters.

So I see my hometown and OBVIOUSLY look at the name. And I immediately recognize it. I know the family. I have met the entire family. I have been at the families house. I had a HUGE crush on their son. I saw one of the family members less than a year ago. I am horrified, mortified and pissed all at the same time. How could I have not known?

I remember driving up the gravel drive way and getting out of my car and thinking that it was a bit smelly and I couldn’t believe all the dogs that were barking. It was soooooo loud. People, I was probably 22-24 years old. I am 30 now. I was college educated. I should have known, but I didn’t. I had no clue what those houses were behind their house. I didn’t know they were breeding dogs in them. I truly think I believed that they were greenhouses or something.

I went into the house and met the family and I distinctly remember meeting a few dogs. I thought it was adorable how the little dog (I can’t remember for the life of me what breed it was) sitting on the mother’s lap and chest the whole time she was in her chair. I find it rather odd how one can form an animal-human bond with one animal and completely disregard the others and sell them off like livestock. I found the following in their USDA reports.

2003: “There was an accumulation of hair and waste on the exterior of most of the enclosures. All animal areas must be kept clean and must be sanitized every two weeks. The outside and inside of all kennels need a thorough cleaning. This affects 161 animals.” 2003: “The openings of the wire floor from the whelping building were too large which allowed the puppies’ feet to pass through. If a suspended floor is used, it must be constructed of metal and the strands must be at least 1/8 inch in diameter (9 gauge) or coated with a material such as plastic or fiberglass. The floor must be replaced with a wire with smaller openings, a smaller opening wire must be placed on top of the existing wire, or the puppies must be kept inside on the solid floor.”

2003: “Animal Inventory: Adult dogs = 161, puppies = 49.”

This could have very easily been the year that I visited the house

2004: “Most of the food receptacles were dirty. There is dust/grime on the bottom interior surface of the feeders and on the metal ledge. The food receptacles must be cleaned frequently enough to provide uncontaminated, wholesome food. They must also be sanitized at least every two weeks.”

2004: “Animal inventory: Adult dogs = 39, puppies = 14.”

2005: “At least six animals were not identified.”

2005: “There were two enclosures that had feces in the sheltered portion. Another two enclosures had an excessive accumulation of hair in the shelters. Three of the wooden shelters had a white substance covering the wood at the junction of the floor and walls. Animal areas inside of housing facilities must be kept clean to ensure the health and well-being of the animals. These areas must be cleaned more frequently and sanitized every two weeks.”

2005: “Three of the enclosures had wire flooring where the coating was not present. All wire less than 9 gauge must be coated with a material such as plastic or fiberglass.”

2005: “Animal Inventory: Adult dogs = 44, puppies = 18.”

So, in summary:
1. The kennels were dirty and not cleaned appropriately
2. They were on chicken wire which hurts their paws
3. There were hair and feces all over the place
4. The dogs feet were falling through the bottom of the cages in the whelping kennel. I am sure this was fantastic for the pregnant mom and her new babies.
So what am I trying to even get at here? Land, the plane right? I lived in puppy mill country and had no idea that I had stepped straight onto puppy mill property. I smelled it. I heard it. I looked directly at a Sundowner. I just thought that they liked having 3 dogs in the house and one of the dogs had pups. They lived in a rural part of the town so I can easily see how they got away with it with no noise violations.

I distinctly remember the guy bringing in a few puppies for me and my best friend to hold. They were absolutely adorable and I wanted one so badly but felt nothing but loyalty towards my collie. I now remember that the whole family tried to push a puppy on both of us. But we both already had dogs. I actually thought they were going to give us a puppy but now realize that we were nothing but a potential sale for them.

So, when people say things like, “People are now educated on puppy mills. They know better than to buy from pet stores. They know what they are buying” I cannot agree. I don’t know how many people I speak to on a weekly basis about puppy/cat mills and the dangers of buying in a pet store. I literally scare the hell out of them as I don’t want them to make the same mistake I did.

I don’t regret buying Zoey for a second. I have learned my lesson and will continue to educate and advocate on her behalf by telling her story to others. Hopefully with her we can reach others.

Posted in Dogs, News, Puppy Mills, Selling puppies | Tagged , , , , , , , , | Leave a comment

Kennel Spotlight – Horrendous Moral Equivalency

In a prior post, I provided a bit of insight into the “fine people” who run the Kennel Spotlight website. A look through its archives unearthed some more instances of good logic and out there thought processes. The article I’m referencing below was written fairly recently.

Act Now.”

I’m not quite sure where or which the part of the article to start with, so I’ll take the most pressing issue. Is it with the author’s decision to classify animals as “property?” Or perhaps it’s with the concept that the Humane Society, PETA and Senator Boxer want to make school menus vegan only over the long term, and not as a response to a discrete issue (and really, what parent would want to put their child at risk of eating meat from downed cows)? No, maybe it’s the author’s outrage over Pasco County’s legislation banning breeders from having more than 9 dogs on their property at any one time vs. the previous limit of 49. After all, what responsible breeder wouldn’t want to bring as many puppies into this world as possible?

No, the author’s absolute low is her attempt to draw some correlation between the effort to stop puppy mills and the HOLOCAUST. I know quite a bit about the World War II era, starting with the Nazis push to gain power in the 1920s and 1930s and can honestly say that any linkage of those years and the anti-puppy mill movement is specious, wrong, and offensive. Save for some of the crazies on the lunatic fringe, pro-pet organizations are not singling out kennels and mills because of who they are; they’re not interested in forcibly converting them to their train of thought; they do not advocate mass murder; they don’t subscribe to a twisted ideology that believes in one race’s superiority; and they do not advocate violence to achieve their aims as a first and last resort.

There is right and there is wrong. On some issues, there are shades of gray. Divining the difference between responsible breeders and puppy mills might fall into the latter area, depending on one’s perspective. But to conflate the confluence of factors that conspired to bring the Nazis to power (of which the actions of the SA were merely one component; and by the way, Hitler moved against them very soon after gaining full power, in July 1934) and the desire of pet organizations to at a minimum diminish breeders’ ability to birth dozens/hundreds of puppies at a spell (remember that Zoey was the 62nd of 80 Cotons born into her mill in just the first three months of this year) is virtually impossible to believe.

How are Jews and pets the same? Organizations are NOT asking breeders to register themselves; they just want to take some steps to begin to limit pet overpopulation. What is wrong with registering animals born into puppy mills? Or with taking steps to prevent dames and sires from becoming used solely for breeding?

None of this is the same as mandating Jews wear yellow stars to identify themselves as such. Or confiscating their property outright. Or by forcing them to sell their businesses for pennies on the dollar. Or by eventually devising a system by which the entirety of European Jewry was exterminated.

The author diminishes herself and her own arguments by engaging in hysteria. She also loses the potential for many moderately minded people to at least listen to what she has to say. Instead, she is simply interested in speaking to the small, narrow-minded group that subscribes to a publication like Kennel Spotlight.

This country could and possibly should have a good debate on issues of pet over-population, puppy mills, and responsible breeding. I know that feelings on both sides are hard and entrenched. But it is impossible to have a decent discussion when one of the parties truly believes that the anti-puppy mill movement is akin to a new-age version of the Nazi party. You can’t argue with extremists. You just have to tune them out.

Posted in News | Tagged , , , , , , , , , , | 1 Response

Parents

Leslie was able to rescue Z’s mom and dad among the dogs she purchased at the auction over the weekend. Leslie arranged for Z to spend some time with her parents. She reported that while there was basically no connection between Z and her dad (save the same spots on their tummies and black/white coat), Z and her mom felt “something” immediately. Actually, Z growled at her mom at first, obviously smelling something that she usually smells on herself. But before long, they were sniffing of each other and being friendly with one another.
One wonders if they knew of their connection. Animals obviously have different senses than us humans (witness Abby staying away from Z when the little one was on the verge of death when we first brought her home from the pet store); dogs sniff and smell better than most. Either way, I’m happy Z and her parents had the chance to spend some time together.
But for our dogs at least, we are now their parents. We care for all of their needs, eating, drinking, bathing, etc. We provide them the love and attention they crave. And they love us back. Z didn’t growl or get upset when Leslie separated her from her birth mom and dad. But she did when Leslie left the house yesterday to run some errands. While I was taking a shower this morning, I noticed the curtain being moved; Abby was trying to get in with me (hind legs on the floor, front on the side of the tub) and started crying when she couldn’t.
What I’ve learned from having two such wonderful dogs, and from hearing about some of Leslie’s experiences in Missouri, is that parentage of a dog is not really who births them. It’s who cares for them.
Some proponents of puppy mills argue that dogs are really predators that Americans selfishly domesticate for companionship. If these people would take a minute away from seeing dogs as a money-making enterprise and instead focus on them as loving, caring members of a family, perhaps their tune might change. I’m not counting on it though. So maybe it’s time to bring the education to them.

Posted in News | Tagged , , , , | Leave a comment

Why we fight!

During World War II, the U.S. government commissioned a series of films called “Why We Fight” for the general public to educate them about why the war was necessary – essentially by spotlighting how awful the Nazis and Japanese were – so that Americans could understand the gravity of the global situation and steel themselves for the struggles ahead.

Leslie is in the midst of a fight of her own right now, for Zoey and, by extension, for all puppies that are born into puppy mills. She knows that she can’t make broad change happen as quickly as she would like. So, instead, she is focused on doing what she can while she can. And she’s started this weekend by flying to the middle of nowhere in Missouri to participate in the final auction of the mill at which Zoey was bred. Her modest goal is to purchase Zoey’s mom and dad, bring them back to Fort Smith, get them spayed and neutered, groomed and then, happily, adopted out to loving, caring families. If she can buy more dogs, or even some of the physical plant the breeder used, that would be a huge bonus.

Leslie sometimes gets upset at the thought that by buying Zoey, in a small way she supported and consequently perpetuated the puppy mill industry. To the contrary, I believe getting Zoey was a wonderful thing on many levels. To start, she has added so much to our family, especially Abby. Additionally, learning about Zoey’s pathology after she became ill motivated Leslie to become involved in putting a stop to this insidious culture. She has done so much in such a short period of time (we’ve only had Zoey since early April) – get Zoey well, make contact with national and local organizations focused on stopping puppy mills, put together groups in NYC herself, raised money for her cause, and finally, undertaken the trip to Missouri.

Leslie’s heart, soul, intelligence and tenacity are going to make this work. The misery Zoey was compelled to put up with for the first 10 weeks of her life, and the thought that thousands of other defenseless animals are put through the same hell every day, is what drives her. It’s become more than a cause for Leslie, it’s become a mission. And she won’t stop until she has affected some form of substantial change, financial, legal or legislative.

Needless to say, I am very proud of her.

Posted in Animal Rescue, Animal Rights Activism, Puppy Mills | Tagged , , , , , , , , | Leave a comment

The Journey Begins

I cannot believe by 4 pm today I will be looking at Zoey’s mom and dad.  It seems like for so long I have been waiting for this but its finally happening.  I broke down last night as I realized that I couldn’t save them all. But, I guess if everyone said they couldn’t save them all and gave up then no dogs or cats would be rescued.

Posted in News | Tagged , , , | Leave a comment